Atherton reduces size of planned civic center

Are you kidding me? Is there any question a new town center is needed? Build it already. This has gone on for 20+ years. If you continue to wait the costs will continue to increase and the floor space will decrease. Was there full funding of the existing buildings when they were built 50-75 years ago? I doubt it. Stop this insanity, we do not need more analysis, portable buildings. The architects will make revisions until the town runs out of money. JUST BUILD IT!

Did cost cutting drive the decision to reduce square footage? Does this mean the city will bring in trailers and storage pods to make up for the loss after the building is finished? If we're going to build this facility, we should not make short sighted decisions about space.

Measure L passed with an overwhelming majority. It says the town center money has to come from private funds primarily. It can't come from bonds nor taxes.

I agree a new town center is desperately needed. My suggestion is that the city council should have a town hall event if fundraising is coming up short. Give the citizens an update on where things stand. After understanding the details and funding situation, hear what residents have to say and what direction they want to go. I would expect that each year we keep our old town center in place means another year of higher energy bills and maintenance costs. It may make more sense to amend Measure L by allowing up to $15 million to publicly fund a new town center, for example.

Athertonians have been willing to approve higher taxes when a need exists. The parcel tax is the best example. The council has credibility to present this case and be trusted. They have been fiscally prudent and improved government transparency the last few years. The drama that used to exist is gone.

I don't think private funding is coming in because the civic center is primarily for staff. Athertonians couldn't care less about "staff." Any idea what they pay theirs or how they treat them? Yep, "we're not putting out a nickel more than we have to for staff. <snort>"

Yeessss,cut down on the size of the council chambers so residents coming to council meetings are very limited, but keep the Olympic size and quality gymnasium for the cops. At first I didn't quite understand the logic of this, but then it dawned on me. When the police-bought and controlled candidates Lewis and Wiest vote another huge raise for these guys, and raise our taxes to pay for it, residents who might complain won't be able to fit in the chambers room, and the window of the gym will be strategically located so they can see some of the cops throwing weights around. Will likely scare them off. I never should have underestimated the strategic brilliance of Elizabeth Lewis!!! But why stop there.. cut the library to 200 square feet and make the gym even bigger, or perhaps an indoor pool or massage center. Invite the sheriff.

makes perfect sense:

thank you for confirming my post

The Town Council has made a serious effort to obtain private funding for a new Town Center and has failed. They did what we asked them to do.

Now let's put a bond measure on the ballot and build a Town Center that we can all be proud of.

I am tired of living in an affluent community that keeps banging a tin cup.

YEAH! It is sad that Caltrans was so slow, but great for Atherton to proceed.

While "Makes Perfect Sense" is being a bit snarky, an important point is brought up by Peter Carpenter's comment.

The Town of Atherton solicited public input into the design of the proposed town center under all of the assumptions of Measure L: that it would be paid for by private donations. It is reasonable to assume that many members of the public who would have had things to say about it if they were going to be paying for it through a bond measure didn't bother to get involved.

I think many members of the public might want to take a look at the design, and whether it is overblown (or not), under the full disclosure that they are footing the bill. The gym "Makes Perfect Sense" refers to may or may not pass such scrutiny, along with other aspects of the design. 24 Hour Fitness memberships are pretty cheap on a monthly basis, and our police officers are already extremely well paid. Perhaps the gym should be open to all residents.