https://n2v.almanacnews.com/square/print/2016/05/07/shine-a-light-on-grade-separation-


Town Square

shine a light on Grade separation

Original post made by confused and concerned, Menlo Park: Allied Arts/Stanford Park, on May 7, 2016

I see a discussion elsewhere that really deserves a light to be shined brightly on it. A study about Ravenswood grade separation just started with a community meeting about the two alternatives the latest set of consultants was authorized by the Council to study. The scope of work is limited two alternatives - Caltrain at grade and Ravenswood tunneled below it, and hybrid of slightly raised train tracks and lowered Ravenswood. In both cases the roadway would be lowered.

This decision needs to be made asap. It needs to be made before the bike/pedestrian undercrossing at Middle is designed because the position of the train tracks dictates where the undercrossing needs to be.
The decision would have a major impact on the Alma and Merrill intersection with Ravenswood, directly affecting possible north-south bike routes. If the hybrid alternative is selected, that decision would also require similar changes at Oak Grove, Glenwood, and Encinal with additional impacts on Alma and Merrill and also on Garwood. According to the consultants, the lowering of the east-west roadways could require blocking these north-south streets. Or require bridges for pedestrians and bikes, possibly cars, too.
The Middle undercrossing, study of El Camino traffic, review of 1300 El Camino project, and grade separation seem to be proceeding in alternate universes. They can only happnen in one, and must happen in the right sequence so the city and developers don't waste money and time. The grade separation decision directly impacts the others and must be expedited.
The proposed project at 1300 El Camino

Comments

Posted by Apple
a resident of Atherton: other
on May 7, 2016 at 7:34 pm

The grade crossing study is set to last for 12 months. If you think the study needs to be expedited, then you'll need to talk to the city. It's not going to happen because it would require more money, but an earlier final recommendation won't buy the city much.

The real problem is funding. SMCTA will likely fund most of the cost for Ravenswood, but not the other three. It's not clear where the money for the other three grade separations will come from if that plan is chosen.

Even considering Ravenswood on its own, I think MP is third in line for grade separation funds. And those funds will likely be depleted by the two grade separation projects ahead in planning: San Mateo 25th Ave and Burlingame Broadway Avenue.