The Bay Area's stay-at-home orders will stretch on until at least the end of May, though construction workers, gardeners and outdoor retailers that can accommodate physical distancing can get back to business as early as Monday, county officials announced Wednesday.
The updated order was issued Wednesday in Santa Clara County, by Dr. Sara Cody, that county's health officer. It represents the Bay Area's first attempt to loosen the shelter-at-home directives that health officers across the region issued on March 16, when COVID-19 cases were rapidly climbing and officials were preparing for a larger surge. The order also lifts prohibitions on outdoor spaces such as skate parks, which do not involve shared equipment or physical contact.
Health officials in San Mateo, Alameda, Contra Costa, Marin and San Francisco counties as well as the city of Berkeley, announced similar measures Wednesday. The jurisdictions had 7,253 confirmed cases and 266 deaths collectively as of Tuesday.
San Mateo County's updated order adds one more restriction than the other counties do: Residents and visitors are prohibited from traveling more than 10 miles from their homes for outdoor recreation. People who live more than 10 miles from the county are prohibited from traveling there for outdoor recreation, but may travel to the county for other essential reasons.
Parking at the county's beaches remains closed. The county is also in the process of restoring public access to some its parks starting Monday, May 4.
The new order also allows golf courses to reopen, however, golfing remains prohibited by the statewide order, which supersedes the local ordinance. (Editor's note: The state revised its order on April 30 to allow individual golfers who walk the course and do not use a cart.)
But even as some restrictions are lifted, the Bay Area's approach also reflects the cautious approach that counties throughout California, as well as state officials, have taken to reopening businesses. Restaurants with dine-in service, bars, hair salons and other businesses that are starting to reopen in other states will remain closed in the county -- and the state -- for weeks, possibly months.
The new order extends most of the current shelter-at-home prohibitions until May 31. They were set to expire this Sunday.
In making her announcement, Cody highlighted the county's progress in managing the pandemic. The county, she said, now accounts for fewer than 5% of the cases in California and just a fraction of the nation's case total, which is now more than 1 million. As of Tuesday, the county had 2,122 confirmed cases and 106 deaths related to COVID-19.
Cody said the goal is to move from the types of "broad-based mitigations" that had been in place since March 17 to a "more focused approach" targeting vulnerable populations.
"What we are hoping is because we have been extraordinarily successful in our region in suppressing cases, flattening the curve and decreasing the number of new cases that we have every day, we are hoping to successfully transition to a point where we can be more focused," Cody said at a news conference at the County Government Center in San Jose.
The order also allows nurseries, landscapers, gardeners and other businesses that primarily provide outdoor services to reopen (which does not include dining establishments with outdoor seating).
The March prohibition on gardening has been particularly contentious, with many local residents and some city leaders questioning the county's decision to ban an outdoor activity that typically includes very little social interaction.
Palo Alto City Manager Ed Shikada said last week that the city has received more calls about gardening than about any other topic, with some complaining about gardening at a neighboring property and others complaining about the ban. Councilman Greg Tanaka aligned himself with the latter at the April 20 council meeting, where he described the gardening ban as "truly bizarre."
Last week, the Atherton City Council asked San Mateo County officials to allow town residents necessary landscaping and gardening activity. This followed concerns from residents about their inability to perform the landscaping work personally; vegetation that would "quickly get out of control" given the large nature of most of the properties in town; and personal health issues related to either the activity or the impact of vegetation that isn't maintained.
Mayor Rick DeGolia called the county's decision to allow gardening to be a "very important move."
But "going forward, I think that it is critical that the county greatly expand the availability of testing and put into practice a comprehensive tracing strategy; otherwise, we just don't know who has the virus and who doesn’t,” he noted in a Wednesday email.
In Menlo Park, Police Chief Dave Bertini said the police department had responded to 530 shelter-in-place violations as of April 28. Most of the calls have been about gardeners or children playing, he said.
Cody said the county is basing its modifications to the heath orders on five indicators: whether the number of total COVID-19 cases in the community is flattening or decreasing; whether the number of hospitalized patients with COVID-19 is flat or decreasing; whether there is an adequate supply of personal protective equipment to protect all health care workers; whether the county is meeting its need for testing residents who are in vulnerable populations or in high-risk settings or occupations; and whether the county has the capacity to investigate all cases and trace all their contacts, isolating those who are infected or exposed.
"We have already made significant progress on many of these indicators and we need to make sure we don't slip backwards," Cody said. "Our goal is to gingerly chart a course to be the most health-protective."
The announcement by Cody mirrors in some ways the strategy that Gov. Gavin Newsom announced on Tuesday for reopening business across the state. Newsom said he plans to transition "in weeks, not months" into a stage where some businesses can reopen.
Dr. Sonya Angell, the state's public health officer, said in a Tuesday presentation that this stage, known as Stage 2, will focus on "low-risk sectors" such as retailers that can provide curbside pickup, offices where telework is not possible and manufacturers that had not been deemed "essential" under the existing order.
Angell also said the second stage can include opening more parks and trails, many of which have been closed to the public over the past six weeks because of concern over physical distancing.
Newsom and Angell also indicated that it will be months before the state enters Stage 3 and businesses that require proximity between staff and customers can reopen.
"Those are things like getting your haircut, getting your nails done, doing anything that has (a) very close, inherent relationship with other people, where proximity is very close. We need a thoughtful process to ensure that people don't put themselves at great risk in doing those activities," Angell said.
What's allowed — and what's not
A modified shelter-at-home order kicks in on May 4 in six Bay Area counties including Santa Clara and San Mateo. It eases restrictions on outdoor businesses, outdoor activities, construction and real estate transactions. Here's a quick summary of what is and is not allowed.
• Gardeners and landscapers: Under the March 16 stay-at-home order, gardeners and landscapers were allowed to perform only essential work needed to maintain the safety of a property. Now, they are permitted to resume all work.
• Construction: Before, only construction of public infrastructure and of residential developments that included affordable housing was permitted. Now, all construction has been added to the list of "essential business" and thus is permitted.
• Real estate: Under the March 16 order, real estate business was not allowed, although the rule that was eased under the county's March 31 updated order, which allowed virtual tours of properties. Now, real estate has been added to the county's list of "essential business." Agents can show a property in person, with proper social distancing and a limit of two clients at a time, even if people still reside in the home.
• Outdoor spaces: Golf courses are allowed under the new county order to reopen. On April 30, the state updated its shelter order to state that individual golfers can play so long as they walk the course and do not use a cart. Dog parks remain closed under both state and county orders because they "encourage gathering." Tennis courts are not explicitly mentioned in the county order, but sports in which equipment is shared are prohibited, except when played by members of the same household.
Kate Bradshaw and Angela Swartz contributed to this report.
Find comprehensive coverage on the Midpeninsula's response to the new coronavirus by Palo Alto Online, the Mountain View Voice and the Almanac here.
Comments
Menlo Park: other
on Apr 30, 2020 at 1:47 am
on Apr 30, 2020 at 1:47 am
Don’t get too excited, residents of Menlo Park. Did you read the email from the City tonight? Our Menlo Park overlords know what is best for us, regardless of what the County and State say.
Based on what science will Menlo Park ignore the County and State SIP rules and retain stricter guidelines? I can’t wait to see. Perhaps we should share our science with the County and State so others can benefit from our wisdom.
Don’t forget that The City of Menlo Park’s decisions are made by people who are fortunate enough to be able to work from home during this challenging time. Not everyone is so lucky.
Don’t forget that our hospitals are empty. Empty to such a degree that it is shameful, given the price we’ve had to pay to achieve this “success”.
Menlo Park: other
on Apr 30, 2020 at 6:41 am
on Apr 30, 2020 at 6:41 am
we would have been much better off with a plan that gave us a full hospital, sick doctors, and plenty of dead. Would have been much better to wait until the epidemic was like New York and the Mayor could look strong giving a daily briefing about the dead, and we could all still be locked down for much longer.. Nincompoops.
Menlo Park: other
on Apr 30, 2020 at 8:17 am
on Apr 30, 2020 at 8:17 am
And yet they have been allowing construction at the Stanford job site? What's that all about? Special treatment?
The rules were stupid. You can do construction on public works projects and low income projects but no others. Either you can do construction safely or you can't. If you can't there should be NO construction going on of any kind. If you can in some cases then you can in ALL and all construction should be allowed.
The allowance of some construction was a POLITICAL decision and not one based in science. Total BS!
And it's total BS that MP continues to keep SOME construction stopped. STOP THE POLITICS!
Menlo Park: Felton Gables
on Apr 30, 2020 at 9:43 am
on Apr 30, 2020 at 9:43 am
> we would have been much better off with a plan that gave us a full hospital, sick doctors, and plenty of dead.
The lack of a sarcasm font here makes your point difficult - a number of whiners were reading your post and nodding as they went, before (if) they realized your view of math and science.
All y'all that choose a 'partial' economy with a 2nd shutdown, over Public Health: what is 'your' acceptable death count? Okay if it's just seniors, too?
Portola Valley: Central Portola Valley
on Apr 30, 2020 at 11:19 am
on Apr 30, 2020 at 11:19 am
Those over 70 should be required to stay inside their homes and not leave, period. It’s unfair for the rest of us to have to keep doing this. We could step up as a community to help them with groceries and other essential needs. But you can’t keep us locked in forever. People around here are getting tired of it and it shows.
Menlo Park: Felton Gables
on Apr 30, 2020 at 11:36 am
on Apr 30, 2020 at 11:36 am
> People around here are getting tired of it and it shows.
Most evident with your previous sentence:
> But you can’t keep us locked in FOREVER.
Geez, friend, get a grip. It's not: waaah "it's unfair"
Once we have sufficient testing and tracing, and the testing shows the infection rate drops from each person infecting 2 to 3 others, we get it down to a rate below 1.1 or even below 1.
Open up before testing and tracing, and the likelihood of a 2nd wave and subsequent shutdown is high. Not worth the risk.
You did partially address the 2nd part of a key question: lock up seniors. You neglected the first part: a 'partial' economy with a 2nd shutdown, over Public Health: what is 'your' acceptable death count?